1st John Chapter 4-5 - The Johns Bible Study
1st, 2nd, and 3rd John
1 John Chapter 4-5
This is an AI Recap of the class.
Some things may be incorrect.
Short Summary of the Whole Class
Our class delved into 1 John chapters 4 and 5, focusing on the central theme that "God is love." The discussion centered on identifying the "spirit of the Antichrist" not as a future figure, but as a present reality of anti-love behavior that cloaks worldly power in religious language. We contrasted this with the true spirit of God, which is recognized by confessing Jesus in the flesh and by demonstrating authentic, heartfelt love for others. Through personal stories and scriptural analysis, we emphasized that genuine love and service are the natural outcomes of faith, not a checklist for salvation. The conversation highlighted that God's love was shown through humility—Christ's birth in a manger—and that our calling is to love one another in the same tangible, self-giving way, which is the true mark of a Christian community that is secure in God's grace.
Detailed Class Summary
The Spirit of Truth vs. The Spirit of Error
We began by reading through 1 John chapters 4 and 5. The initial discussion focused on the opening verses of chapter 4, which urge believers to "test the spirits." The class identified that our actions, particularly how we treat other people, are a visible sign of our faith. This was described as "fruitfulness," which is a natural result of being saved, not a requirement to earn salvation.
The conversation then turned to the "spirit of the Antichrist" mentioned in 1 John 4:3. The group noted that this isn’t just a future, personified figure, but a present spirit of "anti-love" behavior. This spirit represents a form of idolatry where worldly power and values are wrapped in religious language. It's a spirit that denies that Christ came in the flesh, preferring a disembodied, spiritual ideal over the tangible, messy reality of God’s love shown in the world. This is contrasted with the spirit of God, which confesses Jesus Christ has come in the flesh. An example was given of a video that set the Lord's Prayer to images of military hardware, which was identified as a modern manifestation of the spirit of the Antichrist. People are drawn to it because it cloaks worldly power with the name of Jesus, but it is not the message of the cross.
Summary: This section established the core conflict John is addressing: the difference between a true, embodied faith demonstrated through loving actions and a false, worldly spirituality (the spirit of the Antichrist) that prioritizes power and appearances over genuine love.
Bible Verses: 1 John 4, 1 John 4:3, 1 John 4:6
Stories: The analogy of a video setting the Lord's Prayer to images of military hardware.
God is Love and Authentic Community
The focus then shifted to 1 John 4:7-8: "Beloved, let us love one another, for love is of God... He who does not love does not know God, for God is love." The class discussed how some Christian communities can use the idea of "love" to justify hateful or judgmental statements, believing they are acting for someone's "own good." This is often rooted in a "theology of glory," where we believe we must achieve spiritual perfection to earn God’s favor.
In contrast, a "theology of the cross" shows that God’s love is revealed in humility and vulnerability. The story of Jesus’s birth was used as a prime example. He was born in a manger, not a palace, suggesting that God entered the world as an outsider. Therefore, our love for one another is the true calling card of a Christian. This authenticity is crucial. A member contrasted our church’s welcoming environment with an experience at another church where the greeting process felt "so fake." Our church’s greeters serve because they genuinely love people, and this natural, unforced friendliness is what makes people feel truly welcome. It was described as a "symptom of everything's going to be okay," a generosity that flows from a sense of security in God's love.
Summary: True knowledge of God is inseparable from practicing love. God's love was demonstrated in the humility of Christ's incarnation, and our primary calling is to reflect this self-giving love for one another. A welcoming church isn't created by a committee but by fostering a genuine culture of love and fellowship.
Bible Verses: 1 John 4:7-8
Stories: The Birth of Jesus in a manger; a story of visiting a church where the welcome felt "fake."
Perfect Love Casts Out Fear
Next, we examined 1 John 4:17-19, which includes the classic verse, "There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear, because fear involves torment." The discussion highlighted that this love is expressed in how we treat our neighbors. It doesn't involve tormenting them, which is a stark contrast to how some Christians approach "hot button issues." The true point is the people. The Christian hope is not that we must change ourselves to be saved, but that God, in Jesus, entered into our world of sin and struggle to save us.
This led to a personal story from the speaker about his time as a pastor in Arkansas. He realized that people in his congregation were dealing with immense personal struggles—one person took extra pain medicine just to attend church, and another family would argue heatedly on their way to the service. This led to a profound shift in his perspective: his role wasn’t to "beat people up" with doctrine but to give them the "good stuff"—the outpouring of God’s love.
Summary: This part of the discussion focused on how God’s perfect love eliminates the fear of judgment. Our love for others should mirror Christ’s love for us—entering into their struggles rather than judging from a distance. This is the opposite of using faith to torment or condemn others.
Bible Verses: 1 John 4:15-19
Stories: The pastor's experience in Arkansas with a parishioner in pain and a family arguing before church; the conversion of Paul on the road to Damascus.
Loving God by Loving Your Brother
The conversation then moved to 1 John 4:20: "If someone says, 'I love God,' and hates his brother, he is a liar; for he who does not love his brother whom he has seen, how can he love God whom he has not seen?" This verse is a powerful reminder that our faith is about people. Our love for the people around us is the true test of our love for God.
This led to stories illustrating how pain can make people act in ways that don't reflect the "fruitfulness" of faith. One story was about the speaker’s grandmother, who, during a difficult Thanksgiving when she was in immense pain, began yelling at everyone. Another was about the speaker's own experience with intense shoulder pain after a bicycle accident. The anger he felt from the pain gave him a new empathy for older people who are often angry because they are in constant pain. These stories served as a reminder that we should approach others with empathy rather than judgment. This was further illustrated by a story of a waitress at Denny's who, seeing the kitchen was short-staffed, stepped in to help the lone cook without being asked—a perfect example of going beyond one's job description to show love.
Summary: This section drove home the point that loving God is inseparable from loving people. We cannot claim to love a God we can’t see if we hate the brother we can see. Personal stories illustrated how pain and suffering can obscure the "fruit of the Spirit," calling for empathy and understanding rather than judgment.
Bible Verses: 1 John 4:20
Stories: The speaker’s grandmother yelling at Thanksgiving due to pain; the speaker’s own anger and newfound empathy after a painful shoulder injury; the story of the waitress at Denny's who stepped in to help the lone cook.
Overcoming the World and the Three Witnesses
Finally, the class looked at the beginning of chapter 5. We focused on 1 John 5:4: "For whoever is born of God overcomes the world. And this is the victory that has overcome the world—our faith." We then delved into the meaning of the three witnesses John mentions in 1 John 5:6-8: the water, the blood, and the Spirit. The "water" symbolizes Jesus’s baptism, and the "blood" symbolizes His death on the cross. The Spirit is the third witness, who testifies to the truth of who Jesus is.
This interpretation is a direct response to the Gnostic heresy, which taught that Jesus was only a spirit being. By emphasizing the "water and blood," John powerfully affirms the full, physical reality of Jesus’s life and sacrificial death. The session also addressed a textual variation in 1 John 5:7, where some later Bible versions include an explicit reference to the Trinity ("the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost"). It was noted that this phrase is not found in early Greek manuscripts and was likely a later scribal addition to clarify doctrine.
Summary: The final part of the study reinforced the theme of overcoming the world through our faith in God. We also examined the "spirit, water, and blood" as witnesses to Christ's full humanity and divinity, a teaching that directly countered the Gnostic heresy. A brief scholarly discussion on a textual variant in 1 John 5 highlighted how some Trinitarian formulas were likely later additions to the biblical text.
Bible Verses: 1 John 5:4, 1 John 5:6-8
Stories: The concepts of Jesus's Baptism and Crucifixion as historical witnesses.
Medium Length Summary
In this Bible study, we delved into 1 John chapters 4 and 5, centering on the profound truth that "God is love." The discussion emphasized that our primary calling as Christians is not to prove our doctrinal purity but to actively love and care for the community around us. We explored how abiding in God’s love transforms us, moving us from a place of judgment to one of compassion. A key takeaway was from 1 John 4:18, that "perfect love casts out fear," meaning that a true relationship with God frees us from the torment of judgment and empowers us to love others without condemnation.
The class stressed the inseparable link between loving God and loving our fellow human beings, as stated in 1 John 4:20: if we hate our brother whom we see, we cannot possibly love the God we don’t see. Through personal anecdotes about dealing with family members in pain and witnessing selfless acts of service, we acknowledged that human suffering can often make it difficult to show love, which calls for greater empathy. The session concluded by touching on the theme of overcoming the world through faith (1 John 5:4) and analyzing the "spirit, water, and blood" as witnesses to Christ's full humanity, a direct refutation of the Gnostic heresy.
Main Points
Our actions and how we treat others are the visible "fruitfulness" of our faith.
The "spirit of the Antichrist" is a present reality of anti-love behavior that wraps worldly power in religious language.
The defining mark of a Christian is love for one another, as "God is love."
Perfect love, as described in 1 John, casts out the fear and torment of judgment.
Loving God is impossible if you do not love your brother and sister.
Personal pain and suffering can make it difficult to show love, which calls for empathy.
Our faith is the victory that overcomes the world.
The "spirit, water, and blood" testify to the full humanity and divinity of Jesus, countering the Gnostic heresy.
Scriptures and Stories Mentioned
Bible Scriptures
1 John 4 & 5: The primary texts for the discussion.
1 John 4:3: Mentioned in the context of the spirit of the Antichrist.
1 John 4:6: Discussed in relation to who hears the message of God versus the world.
1 John 4:7-8: Central verses for the theme "God is love."
1 John 4:15-19: Confessing Jesus, abiding in love, and how perfect love casts out fear.
1 John 4:20: He who says he loves God but hates his brother is a liar.
1 John 5:4: Our faith is the victory that overcomes the world.
1 John 5:6-8: The three that testify (the Spirit, the water, and the blood), and the discussion of the Trinitarian textual variant.
Thessalonians 4:13 or 15: Referenced as a passage often taken out of context.
Stories and Analogies
The Birth of Jesus: Used as the primary example of God’s love shown through humility.
The pastor's realization in Arkansas that his congregants were dealing with deep struggles.
The conversion of Paul on the road to Damascus from Acts 9.
The speaker’s grandmother yelling at Thanksgiving while she was in great pain.
The speaker’s experience of anger and newfound empathy resulting from a severe shoulder injury.
The story of the waitress at Denny’s who stepped in to help the lone cook.
The story of visiting a church where the welcoming committee felt "fake."
Dolores’s personal testimony of how she found the church’s Bible study after her husband’s passing.
An analogy of a video that set the Lord’s Prayer to images of military hardware.
The Tower of Babel: Used as a metaphor for speaking from a worldly, prideful perspective.
Scrooge / A Christmas Carol: Referenced in relation to ignoring the "ignorance and want" in the world.